AN INQUIRY INTO
THE NATURE OF PEACE
AND
THE TERMS OF ITS PERPETUATION
BY
THORSTEIN VEBLEN
New York B.W. HUEBSCH 1919
_All rights reserved_
COPYRIGHT, 1917. BY THE MACMILLAN COMPANY.
Published April, 1917: Reprinted August, 1917.
New edition published by B.W. HUEBSCH. January, 1919.
PREFACE
It is now some 122 years since Kant wrote the essay, _Zum ewigen Frieden_. Many things have happened since then, although the Peace to which he looked forward with a doubtful hope has not been among them. But many things have happened which the great critical philosopher, and no less critical spectator of human events, would have seen with interest. To Kant the quest of an enduring peace presented itself as an intrinsic human duty, rather than as a promising enterprise. Yet through all his analysis of its premises and of the terms on which it may be realised there runs a tenacious persuasion that, in the end, the regime of peace at large will be installed. Not as a deliberate achievement of human wisdom, so much as a work of Nature the Designer of things--_Natura daedala rerum_.
To any attentive reader of Kant's memorable essay it will be apparent that the title of the following inquiry--On the nature of peace and the terms of its perpetuation--is a descriptive translation of the caption under which he wrote. That such should be the case will not, it is hoped, be accounted either an unseemly presumption or an undue inclination to work under a borrowed light. The aim and compass of any disinterested inquiry in these premises is still the same as it was in Kant's time; such, indeed, as he in great part made it,--viz., a systematic knowledge of things as they are. Nor is the light of Kant's leading to be dispensed with as touches the ways and means of systematic knowledge, wherever the human realities are in question.
Meantime, many things have also changed since the date of Kant's essay. Among other changes are those that affect the direction of inquiry and the terms of systematic formulation. _Natura daedala rerum_ is no longer allowed to go on her own recognizances, without divulging the ways and means of her workmanship. And it is such a line of extension that is here attempted, into a field of inquiry which in Kant's time still lay over the horizon of the future.
The quest of perpetual peace at large is no less a paramount and intrinsic human duty today than it was, nor is it at all certain that its final accomplishment is nearer. But the question of its pursuit and of the conditions to be met in seeking this goal lies in a different shape today; and it is this question that concerns the inquiry which is here undertaken,--What are the terms on which peace at large may hopefully be installed and maintained? What, if anything, is there in the present situation that visibly makes for a realisation of these necessary terms within the calculable future? And what are the consequences presumably due to follow in the nearer future from the installation of such a peace at large? And the answer to these questions is here sought not in terms of what ought dutifully to be done toward the desired consummation, but rather in terms of those known factors of human behaviour that can be shown by analysis of experience to control the conduct of nations in conjunctures of this kind.
Table of contents (by pages)
- 1: An Inquiry Into The Nature Of Peace And The Terms
- 2: When a warlike enterprise has been entered upon
- 3: Men and popular sentiment in a Dynastic State
- 4: Patriotism of the bellicose kind is of the nature of habit
- 5: Standardised under handicraft system
- 6: That the subsidised pacifists have come in for the subsidy
- 7: Where the initiative was taken
- 8: That any inoffensive and industrious people
- 9: Under any governmental auspices
- 10: By virtue of this bias of loyalty
- 11: Of Iceland tenth to thirteenth centuries
- 12: Of this movement lie within the nineteenth century
- 13: In the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries
- 14: Professedly all armament has been designed to keep the peace
- 15: Eventually culminating in hostilities
- 16: And 2 vindication of the national honour
- 17: It is only for warlike purposes
- 18: Besides the preferentially favored businessmen
- 19: As would be the case with ordinary immaterial assets
- 20: It belongs under the general caption of sportsmanship
- 21: Besides that of the national prestige
- 22: The requisite moral sanction may be had on various grounds
- 23: But rather it is homogeneously cosmopolitan
- 24: Patriotism has grown increasingly disserviceable
- 25: Although always of a hybrid complexion
- 26: Something after the fashion of a Mendelian unit character
- 27: Of early neolithic times and later
- 28: The control exercised by neighborly surveillance
- 29: Property rights have displaced community of usufruct
- 30: Quite irrespective of ulterior considerations
- 31: These spiritual assets of self complacency are
- 32: Without the usufruct of the community
- 33: Except on a broad basis of patriotic devotion
- 34: Such a dynastic or autocratic overlord
- 35: Like Russia or the United States
- 36: And patriotism being an invidious sentiment
- 37: While the rights of ownership hold
- 38: These immaterial goods of vicarious prestige are
- 39: It is of no benefit to any of their compatriots
- 40: With warlike enterprise always in perspective
- 41: Which it might seem invidious to specify more explicitly
- 42: Become a sufficiently perplexing question of casuistry
- 43: No compact binds the dynastic statesman
- 44: All these dynastic establishments that so seek the Kingdom
- 45: To include the dynastic States
- 46: It is of an institutional character
- 47: Inosculating with a multiplicity of other norms
- 48: Or rather the dynastic and warlike
- 49: Fell into lines of settled and conventionalised exploitation
- 50: And only inchoately a Japanese nation
- 51: Of the conception of a commonwealth
- 52: Germany is still a dynastic State
- 53: In the one case by a coterie of dynastic statesmen
- 54: Than the spokesmen of these dynastic Powers
- 55: Dictated and enforced by dynastic expediency
- 56: The institutions of the Fatherland
- 57: No less than over the populace
- 58: Through disuse under a regime of peace
- 59: As against the case of the Philippinos
- 60: An excessive adventure in atrocity and predation
- 61: The Ottoman establishment has not observed
- 62: Not subject to British usufruct
- 63: The bureaucratic conduct of affairs is also
- 64: With all this handicap and misrule
- 65: Pecuniary and political liberty
- 66: The analogy of the clam may not be convincing
- 67: In case of dynastic allegiance
- 68: Without the bond of dynastic loyalty
- 69: Such obsolescence of patriotism
- 70: On account of this necessary condition
- 71: Its nearest historical analogue
- 72: The cost of the Imperial court
- 73: They are ungraded and masterless men before the law
- 74: In the shape of a capitalised source of income
- 75: As it doubtless was an unforeseen
- 76: Under modern democratic principles
- 77: The system of large business
- 78: Among the discretionary businessmen
- 79: The businessmen in charge will
- 80: Through this cannily gainful consumption of man power
- 81: Is only a businessman gone to seed
- 82: It is simply that the businessman
- 83: In the sense that this volume of appliances
- 84: Under the rule of business exigencies
- 85: As an asset in usufruct to such an alien power
- 86: Under the paramount surveillance of such an alien power
- 87: But always it is some ulterior
- 88: The conventional Chinese preconceptions
- 89: And indeed the ordinary marginal modicum
- 90: Have become conventionalised and commonly accepted
- 91: The two dynastic establishments seek dominion
- 92: And to such changes only in this body of preconceptions
- 93: One has a vague apprehension that this Ja wohl
- 94: And must put the dynastic establishment out of commission
- 95: Thereby fomenting international animosity
- 96: By the decay of habitual disuse
- 97: What makes this German Imperial establishment redoubtable
- 98: The one excursion was a product of sportsmanlike bravado
- 99: Might be neutralised or relinquished out of hand
- 100: But the neutralisation of international trade
- 101: Not that the privilege and dignity of citizenship
- 102: The peoples of these surviving dynastic States
- 103: To the newer scheme of the ungraded commonwealth
- 104: Obsolete or in process of obsolescence
- 105: Without design or mandatory guidance
- 106: The state of the industrial arts
- 107: Readiness for a warlike defense
- 108: One might even say more aggressively pacific
- 109: Has turned out to be ostensible only
- 110: However distasteful the contingency may be
- 111: And the common defense is a secondary consideration
- 112: On the establishment of such a neutral league
- 113: Because as dynastic States they have no other ulterior aim
- 114: At least as regards its jurisdiction and surveillance
- 115: If the dynastic States are left to their own devices
- 116: A virtual abdication or cancelment of the dynastic rule
- 117: Headed by the dynastic statesmen and warlords
- 118: British adhesion to the project is indispensable
- 119: It also appears that gentlemanly methods
- 120: Whereas their British analogues are gentlemen investors
- 121: The regime may be permanently deranged
- 122: Or even of pecuniary aristocracy
- 123: Is a considerable degree of neutralisation
- 124: Cover all manner of trade discrimination
- 125: Having no political outlook but the dynastic one
- 126: But these restraints may yet be useful for dynastic
- 127: For purposes of warlike aggression
- 128: National animosity and servile abnegation
- 129: To come under the jurisdiction
- 130: By the Entente belligerents or by neutrals
- 131: The chief of the neutral nations
- 132: Be the virtual erasure of the Imperial dynasty
- 133: As a precaution against recurrent Imperial rabies
- 134: Their preconception of national animosity is not secure
- 135: By neutralisation of national pretensions
- 136: Fall under two heads dynastic ambition
- 137: They may be quasi dynastic or pseudo dynastic
- 138: The national honor is a matter of punctilio
- 139: Under any gentlemanly government
- 140: Is a government of businessmen for business ends
- 141: By force of their Imperial character
- 142: The adherence of the American republic would
- 143: As seen in the utterances of its many and urgent spokesmen
- 144: Partly because the national discrepancies
- 145: Among the singularities of the latterday situation
- 146: Or this net loss in self possession
- 147: Has been shifting to the mechanistic plane
- 148: Or which acts as a check on skepticism
- 149: Together with the virtual disappearance of illiteracy
- 150: The menace of warlike aggression from such dynastic States
- 151: The right of ownership and contract was a salutary custom
- 152: Which has outgrown the conditions of handicraft
- 153: And with the further development of this modern technology
- 154: The usufruct of this joint heritage passes
- 155: Which answers to the definition of sabotage
- 156: In the hands of the beneficiary
- 157: These governmental establishments are
- 158: Their office is the stabilisation of archaic institutions
- 159: And passably the British peace of the Victorian era
- 160: Market conditions should accordingly
- 161: That is to say the standard of expenditure
- 162: There is a colloquial saying among businessmen
- 163: Prices than smaller coalitions acting in severalty
- 164: Was small in the Victorian era
- 165: Value of such a line of gentlefolk
- 166: In a meager and toil worn fashion
- 167: Is a pecuniary attribute and is
- 168: Than by the gentlefolk bred of the Victorian peace
- 169: So that aberrant individuals in this class
- 170: The gentlefolk are derived from business
- 171: Must lead to an effectual retardation
- 172: Or that articulate with industrial processes of that nature
- 173: And in the absence of an umpire
- 174: With all its incidents of ownership and investment
