OCCULTISM AND COMMON-SENSE
BY BECKLES WILLSON
WITH AN INTRODUCTION BY PROF. W. F. BARRETT, F.R.S.
_Past President of the Society for Psychical Research_
LONDON T. WERNER LAURIE CLIFFORD'S INN E.C.
CONTENTS
INTRODUCTION VII
I. SCIENCE'S ATTITUDE TOWARDS THE "SUPERNATURAL"
II. THE HYPNOTIC STATE
III. PHANTASMS OF THE LIVING
IV. DREAMS
V. HALLUCINATIONS
VI. PHANTASMS OF THE DEAD
VII. ON "HAUNTINGS" AND KINDRED PHENOMENA
VIII. THE DOWSING OR DIVINING ROD
IX. MEDIUMISTIC PHENOMENA
X. MORE PHYSICAL PHENOMENA
XI. THE MATERIALISATION OF "GHOSTS"
XII. SPIRIT-PHOTOGRAPHY
XIII. CLAIRVOYANCE
XIV. MRS PIPER'S TRANCE UTTERANCES
AFTERWORD
NOTE
The following chapters, together with Professor Barrett's comment thereupon, which now figures as an Introduction, originally appeared in the columns of _The Westminster Gazette_.
INTRODUCTION
_By Professor W. F. Barrett, F.R.S._
_Those of us who took part in the foundation of the Society for Psychical Research were convinced from personal investigation and from the testimony of competent witnesses that, amidst much illusion and deception, there existed an important body of facts, hitherto unrecognised by science, which, if incontestably established, would be of supreme interest and importance._
_It was hoped that by applying scientific methods to their systematic investigation these obscure phenomena might eventually be rescued from the disorderly mystery of ignorance; (but we recognised that this would be a work, not of one generation but of many.) Hence to preserve continuity of effort it was necessary to form a society, the aim of which should be, as we stated at the outset, to bring to bear on these obscure questions the same spirit of exact and unimpassioned inquiry which has enabled science to solve so many problems once not less obscure nor less hotly debated. And such success as the society has achieved is in no small measure due to the wise counsel and ungrudging expenditure both of time and means which the late Professor Henry Sidgwick gave, and which Mrs Sidgwick continues to give, to all the details of its work._
_Turning now to the author of the following pages, everyone must recognise the industry he has shown and the fairness of spirit he has endeavoured to maintain. With different groups of phenomena, the evidential value varies enormously. The testimony of honest and even careful witnesses requires to be received with caution, owing to the intrusion of two sources of error to which untrained observers are very liable. These are unconscious_ mal-observation _and unintentional_ mis-description. _I cannot here enter into the proof of this statement, but it is fully established. Oddly enough, not only a credulous observer but a cynical or ferocious sceptic is singularly prone to these errors when, for the first time, he is induced to investigate psychical phenomena which, in the pride of his superior intelligence, he has hitherto scorned. I could give some amusing illustrations of this within my own knowledge. For instance, a clever but critical friend who had frequently scoffed at the evidence for thought-transference published in the "Proceedings of the Society for Psychical Research," one day seriously informed me he had been converted to a belief in thought-transference by some conclusive experiments he had witnessed. Upon inquiring where these experiments took place I found it was at a public performance of a very inferior Zancig who was then touring through the provinces!_
Table of contents (by pages)
- 1: Occultism and Common-Sense by Beckles Willson
- 2: Mr Willson quotes the implacable disbelief
- 3: Has termed the former our subliminal self
- 4: Faraday's attitude was that of Huxley
- 5: Until normal hypotheses are exhausted
- 6: To hypnotism must the miracle of telepathy now be added
- 7: But telepathy itself requires consideration and explanation
- 8: Gibert m'a t il fait souffrir
- 9: He had told Mrs Sidgwick so at the time
- 10: The agent and percipient have been in the same room
- 11: To make the practice of hypnotism
- 12: The hypnotised subject evincing superior refinement
- 13: Here we have telepathy apparently at work
- 14: Mrs Fox Powys is the narrator July 1882
- 15: The lady glided in backwards
- 16: Here there was not one but two percipients
- 17: I saw the apparition which she saw
- 18: The foregoing is corroborated by Mrs Sinclair
- 19: Later in the day Mr Pelham came in
- 20: Had burst a varicose vein in the calf of her leg
- 21: If he knew anyone named Edsale or Esdale
- 22: ' The Duchess said 'What Earl
- 23: Stabbed Terriss at the stage entrance to the theatre
- 24: Buisson saw his grandmother stretched dead on her bed
- 25: THOMAS LEWIS Herbert Lewis's father
- 26: King Kurigalzu circa 1300 B
- 27: Others while the percipients were awake in bed
- 28: At the exact time of the first apparition
- 29: We thought nothing more about it while in Liverpool
- 30: The account is confirmed by Lord Carnarvon
- 31: Pain is described as resulting from a hallucination
- 32: As to a theory for hallucinations
- 33: The story is communicated by Miss Dodson
- 34: When the phantasm is auditory and not visible
- 35: But directly the apparition ceased to be
- 36: In a subsequent letter Sir X
- 37: Taken from the Report on the Census of Hallucinations
- 38: He happened to look at the square De Freville stone vault
- 39: Three raps were audible on the door
- 40: I should state these as 1 hoaxing
- 41: Commonly pacing backwards and forwards and
- 42: And like the raking of a coal rake
- 43: I shall be glad to receive thy detail
- 44: Joseph Proctor and his family moved to South Shields
- 45: Were unnaturally luminous and piercing
- 46: Until it reached the churchyard wall
- 47: A house on the marsh at Drogheda had been let by its owner
- 48: Kiernan altogether denied the charges
- 49: So far back as 1884 a paper on The Divining Rod
- 50: After making all necessary deductions for exaggeration
- 51: Evercreech is at the foot of the Mendips
- 52: The dowser was a retired miller
- 53: Held in the manner Lady Milbanke did
- 54: The Anglo Bavarian Brewery Ltd
- 55: No new well was fixed on by Mullins
- 56: Sensory hallucinations may be stimulated
- 57: Having been present at one of these seances
- 58: Who was present at this seance
- 59: Viscount Adare the present Earl of Dunraven
- 60: That of William Stainton Moses
- 61: In an organised physical laboratory
- 62: Or by touching the medium or one of the sitters
- 63: Of their collective subliminal capacities
- 64: Who was present at the seance
- 65: Moses and other mediums have done
- 66: He attended several seances one
- 67: Besides the fully materialised forms
- 68: The members of the circle were spiritualists
- 69: Take the famous case of Archdeacon Colley and Mr Monck
- 70: And tactile evidence of the dark seance
- 71: The sitter was posed before the camera
- 72: The judge asked Buguet for an explanation
- 73: A print from the photograph was obtained and shown
- 74: Others are materialisation i
- 75: Not excepting Janet and Hodgson
- 76: Miss Smith's mediumship advanced a stage
- 77: Flournoy bent to elucidate the mystery
- 78: D Things unknown to the sitter
- 79: 'Nelly' said 'Mrs Merrythought
- 80: The statements made by Mrs Piper
- 81: But who purports to control Mrs Piper
- 82: Another who visited Mrs Piper was the famous French author
- 83: Professor Hyslop finally arrives at the conclusion
- 84: That telepathy is insufficient it is superfluous
- 85: Is not the divining rod a miracle
- 86: ADVENTURES OF AN EMPRESS Helene Vacaresco
- 87: And specially designed heads and tailpieces to each chapter
- 88: With photogravure frontispiece
- 89: The Cathedrals of Northern Francis Miltoun
- 90: Iconoclasts A Book of Dramatists
- 91: With 90 illustrations by Blanche McManus
- 92: Pages from an Adventurous Life
- 93: And with photogravure frontispiece
- 94: SKETCHES IN NORMANDY Louis Becke
