A PREFACE TO POLITICS
by
WALTER LIPPMANN
"A God wilt thou create for thyself out of thy seven devils."
Mitchell Kennerley New York and London 1914 Copyright, 1913, by Mitchell Kennerley
_Contents_
CHAPTER PAGE
INTRODUCTION
I. Routineer and Inventor 1
II. The Taboo 34
III. The Changing Focus 53
IV. The Golden Rule and After 86
V. Well Meaning but Unmeaning: the Chicago Vice Report 122
VI. Some Necessary Iconoclasm 159
VII. The Making of Creeds 204
VIII. The Red Herring 247
IX. Revolution and Culture 273
INTRODUCTION
The most incisive comment on politics to-day is indifference. When men and women begin to feel that elections and legislatures do not matter very much, that politics is a rather distant and unimportant exercise, the reformer might as well put to himself a few searching doubts. Indifference is a criticism that cuts beneath oppositions and wranglings by calling the political method itself into question. Leaders in public affairs recognize this. They know that no attack is so disastrous as silence, that no invective is so blasting as the wise and indulgent smile of the people who do not care. Eager to believe that all the world is as interested as they are, there comes a time when even the reformer is compelled to face the fairly widespread suspicion of the average man that politics is an exhibition in which there is much ado about nothing. But such moments of illumination are rare. They appear in writers who realize how large is the public that doesn't read their books, in reformers who venture to compare the membership list of their league with the census of the United States. Whoever has been granted such a moment of insight knows how exquisitely painful it is. To conquer it men turn generally to their ancient comforter, self-deception: they complain about the stolid, inert masses and the apathy of the people. In a more confidential tone they will tell you that the ordinary citizen is a "hopelessly private person."
The reformer is himself not lacking in stolidity if he can believe such a fiction of a people that crowds about tickers and demands the news of the day before it happens, that trembles on the verge of a panic over the unguarded utterance of a financier, and founds a new religion every month or so. But after a while self-deception ceases to be a comfort. This is when the reformer notices how indifference to politics is settling upon some of the most alert minds of our generation, entering into the attitude of men as capable as any reformer of large and imaginative interests. For among the keenest minds, among artists, scientists and philosophers, there is a remarkable inclination to make a virtue of political indifference. Too passionate an absorption in public affairs is felt to be a somewhat shallow performance, and the reformer is patronized as a well-meaning but rather dull fellow. This is the criticism of men engaged in some genuinely creative labor. Often it is unexpressed, often as not the artist or scientist will join in a political movement. But in the depths of his soul there is, I suspect, some feeling which says to the politician, "Why so hot, my little sir?"
Table of contents (by pages)
- 1: A Preface to Politics by Walter Lippmann
- 2: If men find statecraft uninteresting
- 3: Whether you like the Roosevelt doctrines or not
- 4: There is no obvious cleavage which everyone recognizes
- 5: This routine they don't believe in
- 6: But this is no slack philosophy
- 7: They thought in the images of Newton and Montesquieu
- 8: Democracies have turned to machines
- 9: The invisible government is malign
- 10: Contrast it with the Taft administration
- 11: It would give a new outlook to statesmanship
- 12: The more violent syndicalism proves itself to be
- 13: Really statesmanlike things are done
- 14: And drive gambling into the home
- 15: To erect a ban doesn't stop the want
- 16: We rail a good deal against Tammany Hall
- 17: In the comparative success of Tammany
- 18: Instead of tabooing our impulses
- 19: CHAPTER IIITHE CHANGING FOCUS The taboo
- 20: Politicians tend to live in character
- 21: To them dishonesty is a contradiction of their own lusts
- 22: Much that is dead within the movements
- 23: The short ballot in itself is a slight affair
- 24: The method matters more than any particular reform
- 25: Wallas and appreciate the work of his group
- 26: Wallas seems to have had much the same experience
- 27: Any number of social psychologies
- 28: Miss Addams let her impatience get the better of her wisdom
- 29: Both try to found statesmanship on human need
- 30: Until the works of the scientists are matured
- 31: In the Hanna school of politics
- 32: By real problems I mean problems of love
- 33: So with what looks very different the syndicalist movement
- 34: Now the agitator and the statesman are both needed
- 35: Bryan is its uncritical prophet
- 36: Woodrow Wilson understands easily
- 37: And action is guided by hypothesis
- 38: We have begun to guess that ours may be unjust to them
- 39: Other Noras discover their own souls
- 40: Democracy compels law to approximate human need
- 41: There are religious statistics
- 42: Human statistics are illuminating to those who know humanity
- 43: The Chicago Commission had no simple
- 44: Absolute annihilation the ultimate ideal
- 45: For a platitude is generally inert wisdom
- 46: With marriage prohibited and prostitution tabooed
- 47: There are the recommendations which are purely palliative
- 48: Against communication between saloons and brothels
- 49: How precise and definite the taboos
- 50: The taboo entered upon its final illness
- 51: Easily illustrates the possibility and value of diffusion
- 52: Miss Addams has not only made Hull House a beautiful place
- 53: Likewise no statute can end white slavery
- 54: They are typical American idols
- 55: His leprosy was not regarded as a disease
- 56: Class legislation means working class legislation
- 57: But the deliberate casuistry of lawyers
- 58: Language is always grossly inadequate
- 59: Intelligent and strictly monogamous couple
- 60: The unwillingness to cast any bread upon the waters
- 61: The problems that scientists should study
- 62: That hinterland affects daily life
- 63: I have many arguments with my classicalist friend
- 64: And the inevitable classicalism
- 65: That prediction may very easily be upset
- 66: That conscience was inadequate and unintelligent
- 67: Of the morganization of their editorial policy
- 68: Not to announce ultimate values
- 69: I agree with each philosopher as we study him
- 70: Even our evolutionist philosophy
- 71: Machiavelli recognized Lorenzo the Magnificent
- 72: The socialist movement calls him its prophet
- 73: What really demands rationality
- 74: Lincoln Steffens calls these people our damned rascals
- 75: With all his learning he is ineffective because
- 76: Sorel felt the force of these attacks
- 77: Sorel cites primitive Christianity
- 78: For every impulse is imperious
- 79: It is juster to speak of the Marxian tradition
- 80: It has served the socialist purpose well
- 81: I picture this philosophy as one of deliberate choices
- 82: The emerging socialists insisting that not the tariff
- 83: To nourish a fruitful choice of issues
- 84: Judge Lindsey animated dull proposals with human interest
- 85: Cut the lines of party action athwart
- 86: He was talking to a minority party
- 87: Another device is the separation of municipal
- 88: And the Interessenvertrag is a way
- 89: It is turning away from the sterile tyranny of the taboo
- 90: History foreshortens an epoch into an episode
- 91: A convention of the Populist Party has just taken place
- 92: Or drastically reconstruct itself
- 93: The hostility against men like Roosevelt
- 94: The socialists tend to become routineers
- 95: With the exception of the socialists
- 96: There is no such thing as Democracy
- 97: What is the explanation of Wisconsin
- 98: The forces La Follette set in motion are commented upon
- 99: Real statesmanship has a different ambition
- 100: Would accuse Karl Marx of disloyalty to workingmen
- 101: All communities have a culture
- 102: Heresy is just a few hours younger than orthodoxy
- 103: This insight we owe to Bergson
- 104: The fact is worth pondering the Marxian socialists
