* * * * *
Page numbers enclosed by curly braces (example: {25}) have been incorporated to facilitate the use of the Table of Contents and Index.
* * * * *
A SHORT HISTORY OF ENGLISH LIBERALISM
BY
W. LYON BLEASE
_No rational man ever did govern himself by abstractions and universals.... A statesman differs from a professor in an university; the latter has only the general view of society.... A statesman, never losing sight of principles, is to be guided by circumstances; and, judging contrary to the exigencies of the moment, he may ruin his country for ever._
BURKE, "On the Petition of the Unitarians."
T. FISHER UNWIN LONDON: ADELPHI TERRACE LEIPSIC: INSELSTRASSE 20
* * * * *
TO "THE MANCHESTER GUARDIAN"
_First Published in 1913_
(_All rights reserved._)
* * * * *
CONTENTS
CHAPTER PAGE
I. LIBERALISM AND TORYISM 7
II. POLITICAL CONDITIONS IN THE REIGN OF GEORGE III 42
III. THE FIRST MOVEMENT TOWARDS LIBERALISM 69
IV. THE FRENCH REVOLUTION AND ENGLISH OPINION 100
V. THE DECLINE OF TORYISM 142
VI. THE MIDDLE-CLASS SUPREMACY 168
VII. THE MANCHESTER SCHOOL AND PALMERSTON 190
VIII. THE BEGINNING OF THE GLADSTONE PERIOD 230
IX. GLADSTONE VERSUS DISRAELI 265
X. THE IMPERIALIST REACTION 294
XI. LIBERALISM SINCE 1906 324
* * * * *
{7}
A Short History of English Liberalism
CHAPTER I
LIBERALISM AND TORYISM
This book attempts to trace the varying but persistent course of Liberalism in British politics during the last hundred and fifty years. It is not so much a history of events as a reading of them in the light of a particular political philosophy. In the strict sense a history of Liberalism should cover much more than politics. The same habit of mind is to be discovered everywhere else in the history of thought, most conspicuously in religious history, but not less certainly in the history of science and of art. The general victory in these innumerable conflicts of opinion has been to Liberalism, and the movement of the race, during the period with which the writer is concerned, is precisely measured by the degree in which the Liberal spirit has succeeded in modifying the establishments of the preceding age. The object of this book is to investigate the course of that process of modification in politics.
Table of contents (by pages)
- 1: A Short History of English Liberalism by Blease
- 2: The economical Liberalism of Cobden
- 3: The maintenance of rights is the condition of human progress
- 4: Nationalism has stood for liberty
- 5: So nationalism is essential to internationalism
- 6: Domestic tyranny becomes a patriotic duty
- 7: It can only be a question of expediency and prudence
- 8: Of the Toryism of a century ago
- 9: The Tory theory is expressed in terms of duties
- 10: Have rebelled against the Toryism of the governing class
- 11: If disfranchisement springs from depreciation
- 12: Which is the privilege of the enfranchised
- 13: Who are landowners and Christians
- 14: 33 Modern Toryism is identified with Imperialism
- 15: Most mistakenly in their own interests
- 16: The encouragement of local independence
- 17: Exploitation of those races themselves
- 18: As between Liberalism and Toryism
- 19: The history of Liberalism since 1760
- 20: The landowner decided whether any remedy should be applied
- 21: 40 The most consistent of all the Tories was Windham
- 22: 49 The governing class thus used education partly
- 23: Catholics were by these laws excluded
- 24: 55 This is the essence of Toryism
- 25: This drew from Castlereagh a coarse and brutal condemnation
- 26: The penal laws did most to poison their temper
- 27: But the atmosphere of Toryism remained
- 28: At any particular date between 1760 and 1820
- 29: With the exception of this Rockingham section
- 30: Shelburne seems to have had no social prejudices
- 31: Fox was as Liberal in his own way as Shelburne
- 32: Though the general aspect was more definitely Tory
- 33: The woollen industry was transferred from Norfolk
- 34: Inadequate sanitary appliances
- 35: So that industry was never ruined
- 36: Economic discontent invariably produces political discontent
- 37: In 1795 Whitbread introduced a Bill
- 38: For reducing hours of employment
- 39: Wilkes was a disreputable person
- 40: And the exclusion of placemen from the Commons
- 41: The Tories of the American Rebellion decided otherwise
- 42: The corruption of the Tory mind was bad enough
- 43: But the ideals were at least established
- 44: Strengthened the Tory Government
- 45: The voting in 1787 was 178 against 100
- 46: When Fox's Libel Act was passed
- 47: The Revolution might have been averted
- 48: In 1793 Grey was beaten by 282 to 41
- 49: His failure to abolish the Slave Trade
- 50: The meddling with the subsistence of the people
- 51: Was a member of the middle class
- 52: Burdett moved resolutions in favour of manhood suffrage
- 53: 'Right is the best birthright the subject hath
- 54: The one had influence among the aristocracy
- 55: What was unreasonable was fraudulent
- 56: It was based on a false historical assumption
- 57: The quarrel between Paine and Burke
- 58: He advocated graduated death duties
- 59: The French aristocracy had been massacred
- 60: Corresponded with similar societies in France
- 61: 138 Paine himself was tried for seditious libel in 1792
- 62: Or the Societies of United Irishmen and United Englishmen
- 63: They inquired into discontents
- 64: Fitzwilliam was notoriously in favour of the Catholic claims
- 65: But Eldon in the Lords defeated his colleague's Bill
- 66: Pitt himself had apparently no such object
- 67: And by the fraud and rapacity of others
- 68: To use the Danish fleet against them
- 69: In 1815 the victory of Waterloo completed his destruction
- 70: Expressed by Castlereagh and Liverpool
- 71: The British fleet blockaded the Norwegian ports
- 72: The Habeas Corpus Act was suspended
- 73: The yeomen got entangled among the people
- 74: Fitzwilliam was dismissed from his office
- 75: And the Tories offer them a dogma
- 76: Canning was in domestic politics a Tory
- 77: And intermeddling in every way
- 78: This was the philosophy of Bentham
- 79: It is easy to find fallacies in the philosophy of Benthamism
- 80: But the Benthamite reasoning went beyond this
- 81: Viewing capitalists and artisans equally as traders
- 82: By disfranchising the forty shilling freeholders
- 83: Had been disfranchised for bribery and corruption
- 84: A third Bill was introduced in 1832
- 85: With the flower of the aristocracy at its head
- 86: Universal suffrage is incompatible
- 87: Six of them were tried at Dorchester
- 88: But only coupled with the workhouse
- 89: Shaftesbury hated Catholic Emancipation
- 90: But the planters had succeeded
- 91: More bitterly and more effectively by Brougham
- 92: The services of the Whigs were great
- 93: Durham arrived at Quebec on an errand of pacification
- 94: If the Colonies were emancipated
- 95: But the Maynooth grant was a practical measure
- 96: But the Manchester men differed in character
- 97: Cobden and Bright and the other Manchester men saw
- 98: And advocated the reduction of our armaments
- 99: Palmerston often interfered when he had no chance of success
- 100: But the country gentry were not economists
- 101: The Radicals attacked the Corn Law in Radical language
- 102: The League forced its policy upon Parliament
- 103: Here Radicals and Manchester men failed
- 104: As Sir William Molesworth bluntly described it
- 105: For checking foreign immigration
- 106: The latter hated Palmerstonism
- 107: 211 Palmerston interfered to prevent his advance
- 108: When Palmerston flouted their suggestions
- 109: But Palmerston triumphed in the Lobby
- 110: Through Lord Stratford de Redcliffe
- 111: It consisted in the work of Florence Nightingale
- 112: Partly Whig and partly Peelite
- 113: Who was a personal friend of Bowring
- 114: In the quarrel between Prussia and Denmark
- 115: And protested against the dynastic
- 116: The suffering populace of East Lancashire made no complaint
- 117: The Reform Act of 1832 had enfranchised the L10 householder
- 118: Disraeli cared little for his own Bill
- 119: The Whigs were the grand dilettanti or lukewarm
- 120: By the time that the working men were enfranchised in 1867
- 121: He held most of the Benthamite principles
- 122: And to abolish the aristocracy of sex
- 123: To paying for the propagation of obnoxious dogmas
- 124: Was depriving workmen of real liberty
- 125: This was the Licensing Bill of 1871
- 126: Was substantially worse in 1868 than it had been in 1845
- 127: And denounced disendowment as robbery
- 128: But the general status of the sex
- 129: Convenient to the interest of the dominant sex
- 130: It was a crime to keep a brothel
- 131: Seeing prostitution only with male eyes
- 132: In regard to European controversies
- 133: An old subordinate of Palmerston
- 134: The award was for three and a quarter
- 135: Disraeli gratified his instinct for magnificence abroad
- 136: On the lips of the Tsar Alexander
- 137: Soon after the Balkan difficulty began
- 138: The provocation of the Viceroy
- 139: Or the invasion of Afghanistan
- 140: Incumbent upon any Government in its foreign policy
- 141: Without recognizing that principle
- 142: The acquisitions in the Transvaal
- 143: Enforced its wishes upon the members of the Legislature
- 144: And the Nonconformist grievance was removed
- 145: And used arguments against Bradlaugh which
- 146: Boycotting had now been invented
- 147: And had repulsed Sir George Colley at Laing's Nek
- 148: What was right before Majuba was not wrong after Majuba
- 149: And partly to a nationalist dislike of foreign domination
- 150: And agricultural Ireland was wholly Nationalist
- 151: And Parnell commanded exactly eighty five votes
- 152: By a very honest hatred of agrarian crime
- 153: Two incidents displayed this Toryism at its very worst
- 154: A meeting was held at Mitchelstown
- 155: The letter showed that Parnell
- 156: The practical reaction was not
- 157: The Disestablishment of the Churches of Scotland and Wales
- 158: Equality of rate was not equality of taxation
- 159: And its descendants are molluscs to this day
- 160: The fight against cosmopolitanism was not avoided
- 161: And in South Africa they succeeded
- 162: Public morality is not distinguishable from private
- 163: The Outlanders who agitated for reforms of the franchise
- 164: Though generally slovenly and sometimes corrupt
- 165: In 1904 the drink trade procured a Licensing Act
- 166: This work was begun under Sir Henry Campbell Bannerman
- 167: The temporary losses of employment
- 168: May permanently impair his natural capacity
- 169: The benefit of competition remains
- 170: Private ownership of the means of production
- 171: Retrenchment and Reform cannot go together
- 172: Has been greatly strengthened by Darwinism
- 173: The slum creates what the slum destroys
- 174: The necessity of the Budget is clear
- 175: 000 was paid by a man with L20
- 176: Nothing can justify this part of the denominationalist case
- 177: Women have peculiar grievances in marriage laws
- 178: The first is the general Tory assumption
- 179: Is another characteristic expression of Toryism
- 180: 351 In 1906 the movement in favour of Woman Suffrage
- 181: And unscrupulous the militant movement may now have become
- 182: Disorder springs from grievances
- 183: And offered the leaders the first division
- 184: Declined to receive the deputation
- 185: Churchill has neither one excuse nor the other
- 186: The fault was unquestionably not his
- 187: And in 1903 Lord Lansdowne failed
- 188: To restore the influence of Russia
- 189: But he was the only hope of Persia
- 190: And Germany in preventing war between Austria and Russia
- 191: Social estimate of property in
- 192: Liberal and Tory conceptions of
- 193: COBDEN UNWIN and a Critical Study by BROUGHAM VILLIERS
- 194: In spite of rural Magna Chartas
- 195: Late and last Chaplain of Clerkenwell Prison
- 196: Hardenburg and Consul Casement speak
- 197: Lewis Harcourt at the Albert Hall
- 198: 35 Scottish borough members were exempt
- 199: 64 Fitzmaurice's Life of Shelburne
- 200: 106 Political Justice 1793
- 201: And quartered Annual Register
- 202: Castlereagh's speech in Hansard
- 203: 199 Commons' Committee 1825
- 204: Wellington opposed it for precisely that reason Hansard
- 205: 286 Sartor Resartus 1833 Bk
- 206: 316 For the Parliamentary debates see Hansard
- 207: 346 See Fitzpatrick's Transvaal from Within
- 208: 352 Herbert Samuel's Liberalism
- 209: We should still be far from arson and explosives
- 210: My Emancipation of English Women 1913 edition
