THE UNITY OF WESTERN CIVILIZATION
Essays Arranged and Edited by
F. S. MARVIN
Sometime Senior Scholar of St. John's College, Oxford Author of _The Living Past_
Humphrey Milford Oxford University Press London Edinburgh Glasgow New York Toronto Melbourne Bombay
1915
PREFACE
The following essays are the substance of a course of lectures delivered at a Summer School at the Woodbrooke Settlement, near Birmingham, in August 1915. The general purpose of the course will be apparent from the essays themselves. No forced or mechanical uniformity of view was aimed at. The writers will be found, very naturally and properly, to differ in detail and in the stress they lay on different aspects of the case. But they agree in thinking that while our country's cause and the cause of our Allies is just and necessary and must be prosecuted with the utmost vigour, it is not inopportune to reflect on those common and ineradicable elements in the civilization of the West which tend to form a real commonwealth of nations and will survive even the most shattering of conflicts. That we on the Allied side stand fundamentally for this ideal is one of our most valuable assets.
The fact that the lectures were delivered at a settlement for training persons for social work in a religious spirit, suggested to more than one of those who took part in the course, how similar is the task which now lies before us in international affairs to that which Canon Barnett initiated thirty years ago for the treatment of the social question at home. We need in both cases to associate ourselves mentally with others in order to realize the common elements which underlie the seeming diversity in the civilization of the West.
The method of the course was primarily historical, though certain essays have been added of a more idealist type. It is hoped that the point of view suggested, though prompted by current events, may be found to have some permanent value. It could obviously be applied to many other aspects of European life, e.g. morality and politics, to which conditions of space have only permitted indirect reference to be made in this volume.
F.S.M.
CONTENTS
I. INTRODUCTORY: THE GROUNDS OF UNITY By F. S. MARVIN.
II. UNITY IN PREHISTORIC TIMES By J. L. MYRES, Wykeham Professor of Ancient History, Oxford.
III. THE CONTRIBUTION OF GREECE AND ROME By J. A. SMITH, Waynflete Professor of Mental and Moral Philosophy, Oxford.
IV. UNITY IN THE MIDDLE AGES By ERNEST BARKER, Fellow of New College, Oxford.
V. UNITY AND DIVERSITY IN LAW By W. M. GELDART, Vinerian Professor of English Law, Oxford.
Table of contents (by pages)
- 1: The Unity of Civilization
- 2: Prehistoric Europe shows variety of regimens
- 3: And Culture as Factors of Unity
- 4: Which reacts upon the law of citizens ius civile
- 5: UNITY IN EDUCATIONDistinction between Unity and Uniformity
- 6: International co operation has steadily developed
- 7: Willing to make immense sacrifices to avoid an open breach
- 8: Through the concert of thinking beings
- 9: Through many smaller aggregates
- 10: And as the builder of the city state
- 11: Rome had given the framework of a great system
- 12: Naturally a compact geographical unit
- 13: And the sixteenth century thus becomes one
- 14: A truly national government in Germany
- 15: As in the case of anthropology
- 16: I quote from Karl Ernst von Baer
- 17: That Athenian creed will serve our latest ethnologists
- 18: A spade is a spade all the world over
- 19: Conspicuously supplemented by other work of Lubbock
- 20: Where abstention from infanticide
- 21: Not of Paris and London Eratosthenes
- 22: Like the tundra folk and the Algonkins
- 23: Vast featureless and treeless grasslands
- 24: Are rather within the parkland fringes of the Mountain Zone
- 25: And on the Atlantic seaboard by butter and beef
- 26: Or else it was out on the Eurasian grassland
- 27: With its linguistic and religious sequel
- 28: Potsherds are as truthful and eloquent as they are
- 29: And the great Eurasian grasslands
- 30: The tundra does not greatly concern us
- 31: And to respect this common heritage of intertribal customs
- 32: The Anthropology of the Greeks
- 33: Ut inquinavit aere tempus aureum
- 34: Contemporary with our present doings and sufferings
- 35: And especially of Classical Antiquity
- 36: In more organized fullness and more efficacious potency
- 37: This ideal was imperfectly defined
- 38: We must go to school with Greece
- 39: Of inexhaustible and eternal value
- 40: Into the sober designs of grave and energetic manhood
- 41: Under the Empire Rome worked as a master
- 42: To civilize their Teutonic neighbours
- 43: The civilized world has not lost heart or hope
- 44: Quando secundum quod potest Deo adsimilatur
- 45: And from Carcassonne to Magdeburg
- 46: And for the most part only parochial
- 47: 17 Of the three branches of this idioma
- 48: And only depositary of the truth
- 49: Logically this meant a theocracy
- 50: ' 18 Such ampler jurisdiction
- 51: War between States is analogous to ordeal
- 52: In its systematized Hellenistic form
- 53: If they had been better Aristotelians
- 54: And commons are the Platonic classes of guardians
- 55: And there were kings who claimed and exercised imperium
- 56: And not only was extra ecclesiam nulla salus a true saying
- 57: And a little more than a century after the days of Wyclif
- 58: Idem velle idem nolle in re publica
- 59: Die Soziallehren der christlichen Kirchen II
- 60: But a capricious monarch commanding here this
- 61: It was a law administered by Roman officers
- 62: Though perhaps not uniform throughout the kingdom
- 63: The Canon law was the law of the Western Church
- 64: The Code of Napoleon had been a revolutionary code
- 65: The eighteenth century asked for liberty
- 66: That is Public International Law
- 67: The heroic epic and the romance
- 68: Which tells us in a few lines how Tristan and Iseult
- 69: Of unreal and conventional actions
- 70: Dante is the first great artist of a new world
- 71: In the tragedy of Lope de Vega
- 72: From the fourteenth to the seventeenth
- 73: Not indeed the Petrarch of the sonnets
- 74: It was the Lazarillo de Tormes
- 75: The influence of Clarissa on Rousseau
- 76: And near Milton there stands a poet
- 77: Where Faust becomes human through love itself
- 78: For the theory is of German make
- 79: And where there is effective intercommunication
- 80: It derives from the Greco Roman world
- 81: They developed what Aristotle called the science of Reality
- 82: Half reluctant complements to each other
- 83: And this work will be insufferably tedious and
- 84: Before he is convinced of reality
- 85: To the natural Englishman all this seems half mystical
- 86: Will go forward or backward as a unity
- 87: Uniformity in time table and curriculum
- 88: Codified the rules of Latin speech
- 89: And his followers suffered under the new law of heresy
- 90: Luther was stronger than Erasmus
- 91: Their learning remained purely classical
- 92: All this was changed by the Revolution
- 93: The consciousness of a common European spirit has
- 94: The unity of those who have learned to pilot an aeroplane
- 95: But a real unity of life and spirit
- 96: Each feeling wealthier than before'
- 97: And Abraham hearkened unto Ephron
- 98: Io herself was among the captives
- 99: Obviously commodities coming in from foreign countries
- 100: And consequently cheap for him to acquire
- 101: But if commerce thus promotes unity
- 102: Finance is perhaps even more so
- 103: Ousted all other commodities which had been used for money
- 104: It is exactly the same with the borrower and lender of money
- 105: Which is an essential product of commerce
- 106: Manufacturing in semi darkness
- 107: International trade and finance
- 108: Where the interdependence of countries is concerned
- 109: It has come about that manufacturers
- 110: In this matter of industrial legislation
- 111: President of the Swiss Federal Council
- 112: The international meetings of organized workmen
- 113: And an international committee were provisionally appointed
- 114: Delegates addressing the assembly either in French
- 115: And sale of matches made with white phosphorus
- 116: As did few unofficial reformers
- 117: Ministere du Travail Bruxelles
- 118: And as the interchange of ideas increases knowledge
- 119: Certainly causes institutional change
- 120: To deal with infectious disease
- 121: Education is the most powerful
- 122: We cannot fail to call it social reform
- 123: Whether law or administration changes or not
- 124: Humanity is infinitely gullible
- 125: Which is segregated in a world of barbarism
- 126: In these the nations have co operated
- 127: Towards International Government
- 128: First kindled at the Congress of Vienna
- 129: As regards immediate or early policy
- 130: There are those who hold that sheer exhaustion
- 131: Sovereignty is itself divided and distributed
- 132: Regarded as a means of securing world peace and disarmament
- 133: Are not arbitrable in their nature
- 134: 'Will the proposal lead nations to reduce their armaments
- 135: Or by a series of rapid strides
- 136: Prussianism and its Destruction
- 137: Towards International Government
- 138: And while the formation of new sects
- 139: The sacramentalist and the non sacramentalist
- 140: There is hope then for closer fellowship within the Church
- 141: But if I may venture a personal judgement
- 142: Possess some common characteristics
- 143: In speaking of this faith in human solidarity as Western
- 144: Thucydides and Plato assume the same view
- 145: Yeats gives us the judgement of a Bengali who said of Tagore
- 146: Even the essential unity of commerce and science
- 147: We cannot do without patriotism
- 148: Until the recent acute rivalry with Germany developed
- 149: The idea of Humanity first appears with the Stoics
- 150: Appear contemptible and insignificant
- 151: Harmony rises slowly but dominates the final chord
- 152: Which was to some of its earliest conquerors a new Crusade
